Mercenaries and Outlaws in the Tahari
Yesterday I received a group message form Rear the commander of the “Black Dagger Mercenaries”. What is that, you might well think, and so did I. Especially when the content of such message implied several confusing things:
- It suggested that mercenaries and outlaws are the same thing or at least almost.
- It suggested that they are a powerful organization that controls the trade routes
- It suggested that they capture whatever woman is on sight to enslave her
First of all the question does arise: are mercenaries and outlaws a BTB role in the Tahari? The answer is a definite yes. They are just potrayed wrong in Second Life Gorean role play.
Outlaws and Mercenaries are not the same, not even similar. In Fact they are each others opponents or enemies. To understand this, lets look at how mercenaries in the book are portrayed.
The first time we read about some kind mercenaries, is in Tor. Merchants that organize caravans to the various oases hired “riders” or paid guards, to protect the caravan from attacks. These guards however are NOT part of an mercenaries organization but individuals chosen randomly. Their boss is not a mercenaries captain, but the merchants that runs the caravan. They are hired to protect the caravan from raiders – outlaws.
Are those “mercenaries” outlaws? No, not at all . They are honorable people within the law doing a job they get paid for. Nothing dark or bad about that. In the books they get paid when the caravan reaches its destination safely and are said to spend most of their wage in the cafes for drinks and kajirae.
The second time we read about mercenaries is about the warriors of the Salt Ubar. The Salt Ubar had a little army, in fact paid mercenaries. He had them for a specific reason and he also had them structured in military ranks. This is more a mercenaries organization then the riders I mentioned before, yet again individuals hired by a merchant for a specific purpose.
Resumed, mercenaries are BTB, however mercenary organizations are not. They actually make no sense in an environment like the Tahari, simply because there is nobody who would hire their services.
The tribesmen are too proud to leave the security of their people in the hands of hired warriors. Merchants prefer to maintain control over their riders. Also as we can see in the book , it’s easy to contract riders in Tor, why taken the risks involved of hiring a mercenaries “firm”?
Last but certainly not least: In tribesmen such organizations do not exist. The only organisation who comes somewhat close to it , is the Salt Ubars warriors. He lived in a massive luxury Kasbah in the desert and controled the salt mines (hence the name).
His business was not offering mercenaries services but the salt trade. He had hired mercenaries and placed a female captain (see my article about Tarna). His biggest enemy was Hassan the bandit who interfered in his plans to make the two big tribes to go to war with each other.
Now lets look at “outlaws”.
Here we encounter a totally different scenario. Outlaw gangs, called “raiders”, are the norm in the Tahari. Norman chooses to to call them raiders instead of outlaws . The reason for that is, that the Tahari desert is a relatively law-less environment anyway and the line between an outlaw and a non outlaw is rather undefined.
So outside of which law would the outlaw stand? The laws of Turia? Turia claims sovereignty over the Tahari. So from a Turian point of view all the tribes in the Tahari could be considered outlaws as non of them warships the Home Stone of Turia. Despite , Turia has a merchant keep at the border of the Tahari and maintains trade with the oases.
Are those “raiders” outlaws from the Taharian Pashas point of view? Yes, but they are tolerated by the people in the oases. Pashas and their people are descendent themselves from raiders , a long time ago.
In fact raiders in tribesmen do enter freely the oases to trade and use freely facilities such as the Inn, the water reserves, the cafes. In some oases they enter only at night, in others at full daylight.
Nobody stops them, no questions asks.
Tarl was actually riding with a raiders group most of the time, as they pursued similar objectives. Tarl and Hassan the bandit became even good friends.
These raiders groups, where however not powerful organizations that “controlled” the trade routes of the Tahari. The control over the trade routes are shared (depending which ones) by the Pashas of the Kavar and the Aretei (North and Center), by the Salt Ubar (South and East) and by the Turian authorities (West).
Raiders are small groups of men raiding smaller caravans, or people insane enough to travel the tahari without appropriate security measures. They steal from those people whatever they can get, including their women which they trade in the oases for coin.
There are women in those raider groups with different functions (not fighting of course, we know that such thing does not exist on Gor). Using female spies seems to be a common method for those raiders to obtain information about routes certain caravans are taking.
Those raiders do dress like any other man or women in the Tahari. If you would enter a cafe in an oasis you could not tell the difference between a tribe warrior and a raider, other then by the color of the stripes of the warriors kayeff, which indicates his tribe.
Raiders ride kaiilas, they use the scimitar, they have lances and they live in movable tents. I would sooo love to see an authentic raiders group in the Sand Sleen Oasis. The House of Sirnah would welcome them at night, to buy their captives
Sheraka
Scribe of Gor
I am glad you brought up this topic!
The merc commander’s character is named “Raiko Commander of the Black Dagger Mercs of this area.”
I first encountered this ‘policy’ when I was out riding kaiilas in the wastelands with Lady Kate — the was before the notecard was sent out. We met Raiko and a charming friend of his. The claim then was that his “fort controls the trade routes” and that they expect gold “if the city is to continue to recieve goods.”
I wasn’t going to pay them, but instead of just saying that baldly I told them I would ask the Ubar. I still got bonked on the head with a sword, which at least is different from the usual situation where I get bonked on the head with arrows.
At the time I didn’t think they were serious about this as a policy, there seemed to be some knowing winks going between the two merclaws, and it struck me more as bluster and messing around than anything else. And other than the initial sword clunk being emote-less (in my opinion, but it wasn’t a big deal) the rp was fine.
Thinking about it later when the notecard came along I did not think that this interdiction policy could be plausible. As they have a fort they themselves are going to be as heavily dependent on outside trade as the Oasis. Indeed more so, perhaps, as there would be fewer metal smiths and cloth workers, etc. inside, as well as fewer fig trees and bosks (of course fewer people over all too). Also they need a place to sell their loot. A mercenary/outlaw fort would, would think, be more dependent on caravans for long term survival.
Likewise, while there may be individual cases of the people right outside the Oasis causing trouble, as in the incident I was in, which I took to be two tough guys playing rough with the nerd and the hot healer chick. But I can’t see how this could be a consistent policy without, I would think, causing the fortress to be cut off from trade with the Oasis of the Sand Sleen and thus to a large extent from the rest of Gor.
There certainly might be raiders, criminals and thugs, but to have some self contained, impregnable mini-city with its own trade caravans, which somehow has the Oasis surrounded didn’t strike me as plausible.
This was just one incident, with myself and Lady Kate (although I heard a rumor there was a second incident last night), although the subsequent note card made it sound as if this sort of stuff is going to be a routine occurrence. These are not my sims of course, and those who do own them and run them are perfectly free to set up whatever roleplay situations they want. I have no quarrel with that. I am hoping things don’t get to the point that I can’t wander from Sand Sleen South to Sand Sleen and back without having to worry about being shot on a daily basis. That may be fun for some people, but for me, that would get old real quick.
Ok
Just to explain the plausibility of this:
Imagine a caravan comes from Turmus, the last Turian outpost before entering the desert. A “merc” raider/rider stops them to ask for gold for using the TURIAN trade routes. What do you think would happen?
Hint: Turia is the ultimate military power of Southern Gor.
A merc/outlaw group claiming to be “in control of the trade routes” is just plain bullshit and if they ask me such non sense, I go OOC with no further coment or just poof. If the ones who claim that non sense are female I won’t even bother to answer and just TP away.
I reserve the right to do so, because the SIm rules state that we are a BTB SIM, hence I do not have to engage on or accept non-BTB bullshit. If the SIM removes the BTB label I will have to accept such things or move elsewhere.
I hope I was clear enough on that one.
Sheraka
Here is a statement from the Group leader on the Ttopic:
Mercenaries and Outlaws may be percieved by many as the same in some respects as each has their own idea of what each may be as their dealings with them.
A merc could be called an Outlaw by merely charging and over exorbantant fee for his servies or killing one that did not pay his fees. First off the Tahari is not some secrete land that no one can travel to and settle or bargin for passage. It is not an elite country club for city dwellers that pretend that the desert is not a harsh cruel place full of unseen dangers as well as beauty.
Goreans have traveled far in their quest as the Kuri used space travel to go to earth and bring back female and male slaves alike to this world, some were freed some were not some were bred and fostered mixed breed if not then why would they need stabalization serum?
Some became outlaws some city dwellers and some maybe most remained slaves. So if the Kur had such technology the desert is not a place that no one can reach in mere travel. So it is possible that a Merc group could and did come here long ago and their off spring be come more ruthless to adapt to such a harsh environment after coming to the aid of the city here in the desert so that they can survive.
“The high pasha Guru Randwick hired some mercs and outlaws during the the last war with our old enemy the aretai.
The allied forces of the Kavar, the vasall tribes and the mercs defeated the Aretai after a long, hard battle in front of the Oasis of Sand Sleen.
Two of the mercs settled down in a devastated fort and palace outside of the oasis. The life there is a little bit different from the traditional life in the the city or the char camp. They even allow armed women.”
So you see it is what is pervieved by those that read such words not dictated to what is to be as even a slave has a mind and thoughts ramble on. So many things are possible as the mind is a terrible thing to waste. Enjoy
Raiko
BD Commander
Here a couple of thoughts about that:
1. The Kur are not Goreans. The Kur and the PK had advanced technology, Goreans didn’t. These are two totally different issues and the travels of the Kur do not justify any behaviour of Goreans nor does it indicate their travel customs.
2. The Tahari is not a secret land. But it is indeed very remote. In the book people do not travel the Tahari alone but with guides who do know where the water wholes are. It would be suicidal to enter the Wastelands, if you don’t know the desert really well. Taharians are very teritorial, to the point that Taharian people kill anyone who makes maps of the Tahari. Somebody coming from the outsode and establish himself as the super man of the trade routes is just not in the spirit of the book.
3. Yes of course it is possible that a merc group comes along and settles. But its highly unlikly hence far away from plausible and most importantly: not BTB.
However, with a bit of imagination anything can evolve from what BTB Tahari would be.
With a bit of imagination a powerful super strong hyper power merc group has over-powered the Turians and controls the trade routes.
With a bit of imagination all the Taharian tribes fear that super strong hyper power merc that much, that they allow them to control the trade routes and pay them for the use of it .
With a bit of imagination this may even be achieved with female warriors.
With a bit of imagination the super strong hyper power merc comander becomes the king of the desert and the man with the biggest cock on Gor as well.
It is all possible, it just does not deserve the BTB label anymore but is a classic example of “Gor evolved”.
So the question to be asked is: Is the wastelands a BTB SIM or is it not?
Sheraka
Tall all
As by request of the SIM administration, i would like to clearify a couple of things:
This is a general discussion about Gorean role play. I am not against any individuals but I do critisize role play or setups that I find not plausible. It is my right to voice my opinion as I see fit and I give everybody that same opportunity here on this blog.
These articles are meant to be constructive critisism. Please don’t understand them as a personal attack.
Also the opinions stated herein are my personals views and do not necessarily represent the opinion of the SIM administration.
In answer to the question raised about the SIM status: I have been informed that the wastelands SIM is not considered BTB.
Regards
Sheraka